Summary: Link Audits with Tom Critchlow on #SEOchat

Guest: @tomcritchlow of Distilled: . We’ll be discussing Link Audits. @tomcritchlow is responsible for managing the Distilled team and writing killer blog posts. He is also a Distilled evangelist and speaks at various industry conferences. Tom makes Excel look easy and passed his GAIQ exam in 2010.

@tomcritchlow: I’m normally responsible for managing the @distilled SEO team but right now I’m in Seattle working with @seomoz for a few months. I’m also a fan of science and an all round data geek.

Why should you perform link audits and how often should you do them?

This entirely depends on the size of site and industry you’re in. Smaller/nicer industries can get away with less often. But it’s important for everyone to do at least one! @willcritchlow wrote a great post here: The principal is that you should always do an audit before starting with with a new client. To be sure there are no surprises!

There’s a great intro to link audits here: This is a little old but a good one from @vanessafox too: I know some SEOs in super competitive industries who have people dedicated to auditing and monitoring their own site’s links.

@kmullett: Would this be company link audits, competitive link audits or both?
@tomcritchlow: We’re mainly talking company link audits rather than competitive link audits here I think.
@ashbuckles: My question was all link audits but it’s important to segment as well.

What are some of the obvious bad signs to look for when looking at your backlink portfolio?

Obvious things to watch for: too much anchor text, not enough diversity, obvious paid links or any kind of footprint. I think link diversity is super important. Directory links are good for example, but bad if you ONLY have directory links. So you need to balance the profile. If you work with a brand who only has brand anchor text, throw some keyword rich links in! For manipulative/negative/malicious links (e.g. from copmetitors) are harder to spot though. In that case you need to go deeper and start looking at the linking IP blocks, see if you can find low quality link farms etc. Largely I just see links being devalued rather than sites penalised. That said, as soon as it becomes public (e.g. jcpenny) you can get slapped pretty hard.

@kmullett: We do client + competitive audit. If you don’t do an audit you can’t show gain in reports. :)

@kenjansen: How much is too much anchor text?
@shuey03: I think it all depends on what’s normal for a particular industry or niche.
@kmullett: Too much duplicate anchor text which is especially common across multiple site footers.

@jasonmun: I use Open Site Explorer to check for link diversity. Great tool!

@ashbuckles: How much is too much anchor text links? Doesn’t that depend on the competition? I see some #1 ranked companies with 99% anchor text, for example.
@tomcritchlow: yeah @ashbuckles makes a great point. This is all relative, so you have to balance your link profile vs competitors.
@jasonmun: Open site explorer is a good tool If the top 10 links are anchor text links, you know you are in trouble.

@shuey03: Do you see manipulative/negative/malicious links often?
@tomcritchlow: Nope – I don’t see manipulative stuff too often (not that works anyway) but I have come across it and it’s nasty.

@shuey03: Any good tools to help find linking IP blocks?
@tomcritchlow: Best tool for analysing linking IP blocks is majestic:

@beyondcontent: What about getting balance between link diversity and links Google would class as unrelated/not suitable? Grey area..
@tomcritchlow: When I say diversity i’m mainly talking link type (e.g. directory, blog). I don’t think Google looks much at thematically related links…. #controvesial!

@kmullett: Have you tried any of the tools?
@tomcritchlow: Yep. Folks @distilled use them.
@shuey03: @kmullett does @ontolo have any tools to help with link audits?
@kmullett: @shuey03 @ontolo yes, they have many.

@beyondcontent: Unrelated links came up in @econsultancy article this week, newspaper sites selling footer links, blatantly spammy. The case against article marketing by @econsultancy

What does a ‘healthy’ link portfolio look like?

I think I largely answered this in Q2 actually – basically a good diverse mix of links. Not relying on any one type too much. Here’s a good post on analysing a link profile to spot unnaturalness: I don’t know how effective article links will be after the panda update. My analysis here: This is a gem from @justinrbriggs

@jasonmun: What are your thoughts on blog commenting and forum link? I personally dislike them.
@tomcritchlow: Blog commenting is filthy IMHO. That said, I know folks who do it and it’s still highly effective. Sad in 2011!
@shuey03: I believe blog commenting and forum linking is valuable as long as it is on industry related sites and you provide value.
@ashbuckles: I still believe blog commenting has a place, socially. But not spammy, quick, pointless comments.
@JoshuaTitsworth: When you comment to just get a link and not to add to the blog post it falsifies the community.
@ashbuckles: Correct. I only comment when I ‘really’ have something to say.

@shuey03: If you have enough diversity, do you still see plenty of value in spending time building directory and article links?
@tomcritchlow: yep – article and directory links are still effective as part of a healthy balanced diet, I mean link profile.

@ashbuckles: So if you say Google doesn’t care as much about themed links, what are more important factors? i.e. branded links, etc.
@tomcritchlow: I think Google doesn’t look at themed linking because it’s too hard/noisy as a signal. Sites get links from all sorts of sites. Strong/trusted/diverse links are more important than themed links.

@jasonmun: Can you give us an example of how we can leverage social media for links?
@shuey03: Infographics are a great way to build links socially – Great post from @seomoz on infographics here:

@saffyre9: re: Themed linking – do you have any examples/data on that?
@tomcritchlow: Not really I’m afraid. Gut feel/experience.

@tomcritchlow: Hey, while we’re here can I give a shout out to the @distilled Link Building conference we’re running: :)

@kmullett: Check linkback speed to index by typing in exact match phrase in Google then select latest to find when it hits the index.

What are some steps you should take to correct a poor link portfolio?

Correcting a link profile comes in 3 forms really:

  1. You got a penalty. If you get a penalty you need to clean up. Take down ALL the links you can that are even borderline. Then file reconsideration.
  2. You are unbalanced. If it’s just that you have an unbalanced profile you can usually just use that to drive your link building strategy going forward.
  3. Malicious from competitor. If it’s malicious – I’d recommend reporting to Google asap. Google hates that kind of thing. You often can’t get the links down. A useful tip is to watch for link networks – so look for footprints and try and contact the person behind the network.

This is a great article about link building with low quality links:

@JoshuaTitsworth: Would you say updating links rather than implementing a 301 is a good idea?
@tomcritchlow: I’ve heard that using 301 redirects can dampen/remove link penalties but I’ve little personal experience with it. I think that’s why they might work for removing a link penalty. If link juice/effects are destroyed.
@kmullett: Well a 302 would at least make more sense wouldn’t it? Temp move.

@shuey03: Have you found that Google actually listens if you report malicious links?
@tomcritchlow: They listen but don’t respond.

@davesaunders: How do you “clean up” bad links?
@ashbuckles: Sometimes you can request removal of links, take down duplicate content, remove doorway pages, etc. Another option to kill bad links, albeit risky, is to 404 pages and move content to another URL.

@jasonmun: What are your thoughts on Google Bowling? Anyway to avoid this?
@tomcritchlow: It’s actually pretty hard to do if you have an established site. I have *ahem* friends who have tried and failed to google bowl competitors out of the index. Not impossible, but very hard.
@jasonmun: I reckon the amount of effort to bowl a site can be better used optimising your own site.
@kmullett: There are automated tools out there that exist to facilitate such crap via pligg, comment spam, etc.

What are the best (paid and free) tools for doing a link audit?

By far and away the best tool for link audits: I know I’m biased but it’s great. As previously mentioned though, majesticseo is great especially for lower quality links: I also still use yahoo good to get as many link sources as you can. And of course GWT is a no-brainer.

Once you have collected link URLs, analysing them is a must for serious/enterprise audits: Not really a tool, but here’s some great visualizations of link profiles: Let me say it again, @seomoz’s combined with excel is pretty much all you need. Speaking of excel – check this out from @MikeCP

@matt_storms: I have been using blekko and finding some interesting things.
@tomcritchlow: I must admit to not having used blekko too much yet.
@kmullett: It has some interesting results. They just blocked 1million domains! Blekko announcement.
@tomcritchlow: So blekko has pages like this: but is there a way to export/download them all?

@ashbuckles: @kmullett What is it about Majestic SEO (it’s a great tool) that you’re partial to?
@kmullett: @ashbuckles good question. I just think it has greater depth and I like the output.

@kmullett: Do you use many Google operators manually? allintext:, allinanchor:, allintitle:, etc Low return volume though.
@tomcritchlow: Nope don’t use them much myself. Tends to return poor quality data.

@garyjmag: Other than OSE, what is your favorite part of the SEOmoz toolset?
@tomcritchlow: The webapp is awesome too plus new Q&A section.

@tomcritchlow: One final thing, you should all follow @distilled – we have some very exciting news announcing next week :)

Link Audits with Tom Critchlow (@tomcritchlow) #seochat

On Thursday, March 10, 2011 Search Marketing Weekly will be hosting an #seochat on Twitter. Tom Critchlow (@tomcritchlow) will be our guest answering questions about Link Audits.


Starts at 7:00 pm Mountain Time
About 1 hour long
Use hashtag #seochat
Host: Ash Buckles


Questions Answered

Q1 – Why should you perform link audits and how often should you do them?
Q2 – What are some of the obvious bad signs to look for when looking at your backlink portfolio?‬
Q3 – What does a ‘healthy’ link portfolio look like?
Q4 – What are some steps you should take to correct a poor link portfolio?
Q5 – What are the best (paid and free) tools for doing a link audit?

About Tom Critchlow

tom critchlowTom is responsible for running the ever-growing SEO team which includes improving processes, giving training and general support to all SEO projects within Distilled. Sometimes he even manages to get his hands dirty and work hands-on with projects.

Tom is also a Distilled evangelist, speaking at conferences all over the world, blogging all over the world and generally wearing his Distilled hoodie at every opportunity. Interests relevant to working in SEO include a deep rooted passion for Excel, a perverse joy in link building and fascination with analytics. Tom passed his GAIQ exam in 2010, scoring 2% more than Will Critchlow (BOOM!).

In his spare time Tom is usually found studying for an MA with the Open University, training in Wing Chun with Austin Goh or learning to play the piano. Other interests include; poker, board games, books, music, cooking, chess and juggling.

  • xxx free fuck me videos
  • beautiful erotic black teens
  • retro shemale anal porn movies
  • erotic short stories author blackwind
  • sucking boobs pics
  • Indian lesbian fucking
  • young teen model toplist
  • young girls having xxx sex
  • female playing with pussy
  • hot topics girl plushy
  • Huge boobs girl
  • scottish mp threesome sex scandal
  • exotic latin models ass pics
  • swingers girls and bjs
  • nina hartley eating black pussy
  • is oral sex biblically wrong
  • Shake it that ass
  • Teen titans pic
  • teen girls stars having sex pics
  • teenager girls squirting
  • flash teen pussy
  • chicks crying tears from anal
  • jiggle black booty riding dick
  • chubby girl fingering herself
  • mature amateur women pics
  • the sexiest free shemale videos
  • teenie blowjob lips tongue suck
  • free xxx mature lessons
  • free download shemale xxx
  • babes pics free hot
  • facial abuse girls
  • free black hairstyles pictures
  • shemale free psp video
  • young teen amateur bikini
  • fuck pictures free tit
  • Forced to have lesbian sex
  • sex photos of amateur porno models
  • beautiful brunettes gallery
  • naked married couples having sex
  • teen girls porn under
  • teens girls hungry for sex
  • girl fucked by big cock videos
  • infant picture rash facial
  • neil youngs first wife
  • fuck anal black
  • roxy sex robot nude pics
  • independent movies sex scenes
  • old black white pictures churning butter
  • closeup teen vulva
  • girl young illegal
  • sexy female almost nude bikini models
  • free spread pussy closeup
  • amateur iranian couple having sex video
  • girls videos free updates
  • Russian ass pics
  • indian pakistani hardcore movies
  • wife training videos slut
  • sabrina the teenage girl porn
  • fucking hardcore video
  • hardcore lesbian anal tube
  • submitted mature nude wives photos
  • hardcore fucking party
  • Lick the ass
  • sex old and teen
  • french presidents wife nude pictures
  • free husband wife son videos
  • asian chub free video
  • wiild and crazy naked girls
  • lesbian teen anal double dildo
  • amaeteur mature women young men videos
  • metacafe betty blue orgasm video
  • Emma watson fake sex pictures
  • lesbian shemale sex videos
  • amateur lesbian sex video
  • teen and having sex
  • young teen tita
  • medicine black beauties
  • girl gets pounded video
  • sex masseuses girls
  • how to properly eat a pussy
  • models xxx young
  • interacial tits free pics
  • teens pussy sleeping on tube
  • free sex granny video
  • hot naked girls lsg
  • vicky valentne uk glamour girl babestation
  • anal black shemale dildo
  • free shemale porn videos corsets
  • mri of sex and video
  • Young nude girl movies
  • Lesbian sex in bathtub
  • tammy cock virgin pussy break cherry
  • white teens fucking black men
  • softcore porn streaming video
  • the girl next door full video
  • domination shemale movies
  • pics of girls getting fat
  • wifes forced first anal
  • young pornstars hardcore
  • porn galleries mature plumpers
  • hardcore oral xxx videos
  • girls tricked into having sex
  • naked woman photo gallery
  • Fucking wet pussies
  • girl gymnastics gallery
  • college girls pornhub
  • free online pain anal porn movies
  • sex videos old couples
  • Naked ladies flowers
  • tan teen beach girls
  • free hardcore blow jobs movie previews
  • teen party sex tubes
  • naked teen groups photo galleries
  • teen movie club
  • mature fucked through pantyhose free video
  • free oral cumshot video
  • fuck pussy solo girl masturbation
  • teen girls coming of age
  • paki girls sex
  • Lesbian sex gallerys
  • simpisons porn pics
  • teen fuck in the office
  • adult free amateur videos
  • russian beauties petite
  • eating sperm from her pussy
  • free dildo movie orgasm
  • Simran nude videos
  • porn from japan
  • mature xxx pointy nipples
  • black pics naked
  • russian teenage fuck
  • Jessica sierra sex tape pics
  • woman orgasm video sybian
  • black pregnant women porn
  • online blonde sex movies
  • how to fuck womenfuck videos
  • rate girls boobs
  • how to give girl good orgasm
  • hot tamilian chicks dick sucking
  • hardcore hot pussy and penis
  • sexy japaneses boobs massage
  • cum in pussy and mouth
  • shemale japan free pictures
  • young chinese blowjob
  • petite blond showering
  • golden shower female xxx porn free
  • free asian lactation movies
  • wife bgs for black cock
  • porn videos of lisa simpson
  • better sex vids books
  • Girl fucking video
  • devon pornstar gallery
  • glamour girl ngalleries
  • wet beauty girl
  • mmf teen tubes
  • ebony big tit porn
  • bikini tanlines pics
  • anal sex with suction cup dildo
  • enama cartoon sex videos
  • free homemade mature swingers video
  • Nude video of jennifer lopez
  • sexy hot babes pics
  • teen amuatur blowjob
  • young housewife accidentally becomes porn star
  • oral sex pics girl on girl
  • japan sex models
  • xxx fucking my firends wife
  • british amateur mature models pics
  • gallery boobs pussy asian
  • butt anal asian lickers
  • girl learning to give a handjob
  • fat girl crying porn
  • f fucking asian movie
  • wife black cock free
  • slut young sex
  • brunette mom free sex video
  • assfucked teen toying pussy
  • mimi macpherson sex videos
  • wife orgies amateur galleries
  • white chicks vs black monster cocks
  • girls using toys xxx
  • gagging amutuer blowjob videos
  • wifey blowjob free
  • naughty girls rough sex
  • porn free videos
  • young teens big cock
  • index of pink pussy
  • teen girls in boots
  • naked girl in shower videos
  • Teen free ebony
  • houston sex movie
  • asian anal xx
  • list of anal pornstars
  • japan teacher fucking girl student
  • sexporn granny shemale free video
  • milf gangbang sex video
  • Sex toys home made
  • panty girl little butt ass
  • amateur goth girl pics
  • hot nude japanese chicks
  • wbe cast naked girls
  • college coeds drunk sex video
  • free naked wild party girls
  • vids of frat party girls fucked
  • pictures of girl with boots
  • school girl porn eskimo
  • wonderful blowjob video
  • asian sex party
  • girls playing nude twister pics
  • Shyla stylez asses in public video
  • free ebony lesbian porn
  • big chubby sexy fucking porn videos
  • free pics young round ebony
  • parent directory video porn
  • how to sex videos free
  • free blowjob trailers xxx
  • free cumshot facial young girls
  • gothic fuck schoolgirl sex porn
  • Asian teen lesbians having sex
  • smut moms pussy movie
  • ranchy mature women picture
  • wet young pussy xxx
  • Nude girls uk
  • wild mature older office workers movies
  • free sex amateur homemade videos
  • free teen boy vids hairless
  • index of young girl
  • extreem porn videos free very young
  • lesbian redneck sex
  • drunk wife party sex story
  • hot porn chicks
  • anal porn stars
  • Anal cream pie pics
  • girls lose their virginity porn
  • raver beauty pussy videos
  • chunky cubby teen girls naked
  • Korean teens sex
  • shemale pornstar angel blonde
  • asian amateurs school girls
  • amateur girlgirl videos
  • best mature with lads movies ever
  • drunk girls and sex
  • free sex video free blue
  • mature anal french women
  • beautifull pussy pic
  • naked female pussy
  • falkovideo teen girls
  • oral sex shved pussy blodes
  • history of japanese oral tradition
  • anal masturbation chicks
  • upload and watch free porn videos
  • naked pictures thumbs young
  • hypnotized reality videos
  • teenage chestnut blonde
  • tight wet teen pussy sex
  • huge cock anal vids
  • fuck a dead body pictures
  • teen ebony blowjob
  • ass breast and sex
  • asian black internal slutload
  • mischa barton pussy
  • hot university babes fucking video gallery
  • stream totally free lesbian porn videos
  • teen girl sucks dick
  • teen homeade sex tubes
  • barely videos anal
  • bubble butt teen
  • sexy woman in black stockings
  • sexy teen boob pics
  • young screaming porn
  • bbw mature pictures
  • free porn trailers lesbians tribbing
  • naked black girls oiled
  • Sexy girls snogging
  • Ufc girls nude
  • naked girls kissing and having sex
  • tall girls nice tits
  • really sexy ebony couple
  • free young sexy boys movies
  • Paris hilton sex tape photo
  • naked very young models
  • nude sexy slim teens
  • shemale tranny fist anal
  • handicap friend wants to fuck movies
  • sexy tits girl on girl
  • video amateur xxx gratuite
  • amateur nude pics filipina
  • two cute girls fuck guy
  • black and cream flower girl dresses
  • nude young small tits
  • lesbian young women
  • blonde teen college
  • shemale blowjobs by girls
  • free men sex with pics
  • ameteure lesbien hardcore
  • sexy busty asian
  • threesome porn star videos
  • petite white women fucking
  • teen dance party dj
  • xxx shemale goess black pictures
  • tiny tight creampie anal movies
  • teen wives naked
  • sexual assaulted teens
  • old guys and young girl
  • petite jag jeans
  • free petit pussy photos
  • free thumbnail gallery persian girls
  • harley motorcycle from movie black rain
  • girl round butt
  • free porn sites teen cumshots
  • videos of nude filipina girls
  • pics of vince young
  • hot busty babes videos
  • videos about better anal sex
  • dustin diamond porn watch video
  • teen girls drunk wild
  • topless girl brushing teeth video
  • prefect black breasts
  • little pussy full cum
  • Girls teen bedrooms
  • couple sex porn free movie
  • final fantasy chicks xxx
  • Teen dildo public
  • nude horny sexy black women porn
  • japanese girls nude free videos
  • watch young black pussy free
  • xxx porn channels
  • naked teenies thunbnail
  • nudists couples pictures
  • swinging wife videos
  • sexy videos young
  • stockings basque anal sex
  • massive saggy breasts movies
  • How to masturbate yahoo
  • hot lesbian ass licking
  • teen black boys videos
  • hot spanish girls get butt fucked
  • sexy shemale blow jobs
  • free butts galleries
  • emmanuelle seigner porn movie galleries
  • free young teen full porn videos
  • free video of my wife uk
  • black puma hungarian beauty
  • gonzo girls blowjob
  • videos sex cam gratuit
  • Shave that pussy
  • non nude young girls
  • young girl spandex pics
  • black chevy tahoe pictures
  • she fucks her mothers ass videos
  • topless college girls
  • donkey having sex with woman videos
  • petite chicks big dick videos
  • free hairless closeup pussy pics
  • two guys one girl sex video
  • young sexy models teens erotic
  • amateur self pics guys
  • stories about wife having sex
  • just hot wet pussy
  • girl next door bend over pussy
  • mature free pics list nurse
  • youngest german porn
  • puffy pussy creampie pornhub
  • real teen ex girlfriends videos free
  • xxx porn streaming upload
  • hot girls with big pierced tits
  • does anne hathaway like oral sex
  • asian girl handjob pov
  • black mature moms banging
  • mom blackmailing sex
  • fairly o parents porn videos
  • russian titty fuck videos
  • glamour girls tits milfs
  • videos of girls riding guys
  • black banazza xxx
  • hardcore vids gallery
  • Sex tapes india
  • Naked teens videos
  • free thick sex videos
  • dustin lance black nude sex shots
  • Teen jailbait videos
  • hot asian wifes
  • black female breasts
  • Pamela anderson sex vid
  • big tiity teens videos
  • free big butt girls getting fucked
  • free couple fuck teen
  • car in pussy
  • big tits free movies streaming
  • wild party girls ss
  • christine young porn movies free
  • finger fuck granny porn
  • little teens nude pics
  • free amateur orgasm video
  • free hardcore mature sex pictures
  • free young pussy movie family naked
  • hottest girls youngest porn site
  • black teen pussy white dick
  • milf couples pictures
  • hot blonde teen girls in bikinini